Saturday, March 5, 2011

Here's the beastie!

All my case notes from the Hamilton clinic of Fertility Associates arrived yesterday.

I saw the envelope in the letterbox and I had to just grab it and basically run to the front door! I was so nervous. I put it on the chair without opening it, and looked at it. This was the moment I would finally see the dreaded CPAC form that the clinic had used to deny us funding for fertility treatment. Then I decided I was being silly and tore into it. Here's what I got:

CPAC form - the real one that FA used to score us   :(
You may not have immediately noticed, but see if you can spot the difference between the form above (written not by the Ministry of Health or any other official government body, but by the very clinic manager who has been such a pain.in.the.arse to me) and the form below...


Picture of "official" (as far as I know) form:

The CPAC form that I found online. Spot the difference?
I dunno, the form from FA just looks bogus. There are many differences between the two, but perhaps the most surprising thing is that instead of scoring us the way I had expected, the numbers are a little different too.

For instance, obviously the consultant from FA had only given us a tiny score for "Duration of Infertility", but she had also, unexpectedly, given us the highest possible marks for "Number of Children". I thought that we would only get an (8) for that question, but since the FA form is worded "Children at Home" rather than "Number of Children" we scored a (30). Which was a little say of sunshine in this paperwork quagmire! lol :P

Yeah, so instead of getting a (50) for "Duration of Infertility", we only got a (20). Stinky poos. The form obviously doesn't say ANYTHING about penalising us because hubby has a vasectomy. In fact, the only other place we lost marks was the question "Sterilisation", where we got a (10) half marks.

FA gave us a 60. Minimum pass score is 65. I thought we were due a 68. Turns out we are due a 90!!!

Well! That's more like it!

Now, I only have a couple of things to do:

Contact the Doctor who was on the advisory board that figured out how the CPAC form should be made. Hopefully he will be able to answer my questions about the form. I'm pretty sure that the one FA is using is NOT identical to the "official" one authorised by the National Health Committee.

Contact my diabetes endocrinologist, and share this news with him. He's been really helpful and supportive of this crusade so far. I'm sure he will be most interested.

Contact the advocate from the Health and Disability Commissioner's office, who, unfortunately, gave me a defunct email address so has received nothing I've sent her for the last month. Dumb. Phone it is, then.

Update the Member of Parliament. He's promised to contact the Ministry of Health on our behalf.

Get-writin' my letter of complaint to Fertility Associates Hamilton. Because, no matter how this turns our, so far I am not impressed.

I am incredibly relieved that the CPAC form FA sent me proves my theory, so far. My theory that they have illegally and unlawfully discriminated against us and artificially lowered our score by 30 points, OR perhaps, they just don't know how to use the form properly. Which, for a medical establishment, is a worry in itself.

I think that the first option is more likely. That way, FA are hoping we will give in and pay for private treatment. But we just can't afford it. And this is putting my life on hold. I have to do this right. It's a delicate situation, like trying to hold a jelly in your hands without letting any slip. I feel like if I give too much away, show my cards to early, FA will just steal all my hard work away and not change our score. And not let us have access to funding, or treatment, or pregnancy, or birth, or motherhood.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Email back from Hamildog

Dear [Kaitake]

I am sorry you found my explanation of the Ministry’s criteria for publicly funded fertility treatment unsatisfactory. I am sure you can appreciate our obligation to adhere to the Ministry’s guidelines relating to patient scoring as these apply nationally.
Please let me know if you have further information you wish we take into account or if you require further clarification.
As requested, I have posted to you today all your file documentation, including the CPAC scoring sheet.

Kind regards,
Hamilton FA Clinic Manager


So, as you can see she totally still thinks she's in the right and is still backing her doctor. But she's still wrong!!!!

The documents I requested are now in the post, so we will finally get to see where they dropped the 8 points off our form. Should be interesting. My heart pounds and I break out in a sweat just thinking about it.

Maybe she finally sent me the CPAC form because of all the big bananas I had cc'd on my email? Cos she replied pretty promptly and cc'd everyone back, MP, doctor, HDC advocate, husband. Dunno but I suspect that's a good thing? Do you think she sounds hard-arse, or is she just getting all defensive???


- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone

Saturday, February 26, 2011

I sent the Hamilton FA Clinic an email...

...take this, you b*tch!

Hi [Clinic Manager Lady],

Thank you for reviewing our case. As you can guess, this is not the result we were hoping for.

When we met with Dr R and were scored for access to funding for fertility treatment, I asked for a copy of the form she used to work out our score. She refused to give me a copy. I believe that this is not in accordance with my rights as a patient.

I am now requesting that you send me a copy of the CPAC form used at our consultation, and all other case notes you have for us. ALL case notes please. I am interested to know how we came to score a 60 on the CPAC form, and how Dr R came to that particular number, as she could not explain it very well at our consult.

Please post me a copy, or scan and email me a copy of all case notes.

My address is...

My email address is...

Furthermore, I would like to let you know that I do not feel you have taken my concerns into account or even given me a chance to explain them properly. I would like to submit a formal complaint. I shall send this to you via email over the coming week, as time permits.

I look forward to hearing from you,

Regards,
[Kaitake]

Oh, yeah, and I cc'd it to my husband, the MP, my diabetes endocrinologist (who used to be a fertility endo back in the USA), and the lovely lady at the Health and Diasability Commission who has offered to help.

So yeah, take that, you sucky Hamilton Clinic Fertility Associates Manager!!

p.s. I'm removing comment moderation, as a trial, because I figure you're all lovely people and I would like to make things easier for you :) Let me know if you like!

p.p.s. spent a lovely day today with hubby (it's a Saturday) shopping this morning, having lunch with my in-laws, walking in the bush, and then hubby cooked a fantastic vege mousaka! Nom!

Friday, February 25, 2011

A positive meeting with my local MP

I was pretty nervous. I joked to myself that my nerve felt worse than when I was going to my last job interview! haha :P I deliberately parked a couple of blocks away from the MP's (Member of Parliament) office so I would have time to walk and get rid of some of my nervous energy. It worked pretty well, and by the time I got to the offices, I was feeling calm and confident.

The MP (let's call him J) had done his homework; he knew that I was a tutor, and asked how "school" was. So I was put instantly at ease as we chatted about the field trip I was involved with this morning.

We went into a shiny new meeting room, with a round table to sit at - nice, since I was expecting a desk. There was plenty of room to spread out my documents, and since J had a notepad to take notes, I got one out of my satchel too. I felt like it was a very comfortable and respectful meeting :)

I showed him the CPAC form, which I had filled out how I believe it should have been in the first place, and he checked through it carefully. He mentioned that he had re-read my letter several times. The letter turned out to be a good idea, because I didn't have to waste time telling all my story, we could just concentrate on talking about what was wrong, why it went wrong, and how to fix it.

We discussed the maternal instinct and how you can't just switch it off. How his father remarried and had his (J's) brother when the father was 55 - so I felt he was understanding and compassionate to our case with mine and hubby's age difference (did you follow that?). We talked about health funding, and I mentioned that infertility is recognized as a disease by the WHO. I said how I felt that if it was just my husband being scored, then maybe yes, it would be fair, but for me, who has never had a child, it's not fair, thus it's not fair for us as a couple to be treated like this. He wanted to make sure that he understood that we did not have unexplained infertility, and asked it waiting 3 years would help out case. He could easily see that it wouldn't! I felt reassured to see he also could not see the logic in it all. I made sure to say how we suspected the Hamilton Clinic of Fertility Associates had artificially lowered our score, andI felt they were now giving our complaint the brush-off. I must admit to taking only minimal notes, and I was doing a lot of the talking, so I don't have a verbatim record of our conversation.

But...

then he asked "how would you like me to help you?" How good is that? I had a copy of my letter, and I said "well, I wrote a wishlist in my letter for you!" I said that ideally, we would like to be treated fairly and that to us, that would mean having our scored changed from the 60 (fail + false) to the 68 (pass + how it should be!!), as well as having our time on the waiting list back-dated to the point of our consult with the fertility specialist, since that is when all this palava started. I also made sure to say that it felt like I might as well ask Santa, since I knew that he probably couldn't just wave a magic wand and make that happen - oh, and for us to be put on the waiting list, someone else might have to be bumped back or off it! Awful!

He thought for a minute, then said he would ring the Ministry of Health, to ask for their advice on our next steps.

I said I would contact the Hamilton Clinic again and this time, ask for a copy of my CPAC form, my ACTUAL form, which they refused to give me a copy of at the consult. As a patient, I'm legally entitled to see it. I can't wait to see where they think they took the 8 points! Honestly, even using all sorts of permutation on the form, I could not get it to spit out a 60! :S

He also said that, if I was comfortable, he would like it if I could keep him up-to-date with anything relevant to our case. So now I'm on a first-name + email basis with my MP. Cool.

I must say I left the office feeling quite light and positive. I never expected it to go so well.

- - - - - -

My apologies if this whole post is a bit shoddily written. I pretty tired. Apart from the nerves I had before my meeting, I had a full day at work too!

As soon as I got into work one of my colleagues (the one who called his father in Christchurch and got cut off) asked if I could help out with transporting students to a field trip later - he had booked an institute van, but then extra students had enrolled into his class that morning (that's art students for you!) but it wasn't enough students worth renting a bus for. So I drove 3 students in my personal car, which was nice, as it meant I was able to go with one of the new students, who I'd just transferred into the class when she turned up at the office nearly in tears because she was afraid the level of course she had chosen was too hard. I got her fixed up and finished all the change of programme paperwork, then introduced her to her new classmates and travelled with them to the field trip. We visited 3 galleries in quick succession. I found a simply gorgeous bird bath by a local ceramics artist that will be fantastic in our back garden. Oh! I'm so naughty, it was a bit expensive. I pick it up tomorrow and will post pictures for you to see :)

The stress of the day made me go quite high, but I was super-worried about over-bolusing, especially when I was driving students around the place.

After lunch, and the meeting with the MP, I went back to work and did a couple of hours research into eBooks (I'm helping out the e-learning department here at work) and had a couple of intense discussions with the colleague on the other side of my desk... whew!

I picked up hubby on the way home from work (his kidney stones are better, for now, he passed a MASSIVE one! Blood tests were pretty good but showed slightly raised blood pressure so we are modifying our diet a bit and hubby is increasing his exercise by walking to work which is cool. He also had a CT scan, but hasn't yet got the results back) and then we went to see my Mum and have a cuppa tea. Little sister turned up too, which is cool as sometimes I don't get to see her as often as I'd like.

I am sooooooooo glad it's the weekend!

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Christchurch Earthquake

Yesterday a massive earthquake stuck one of the main cities in New Zealand: Christchurch. They had a big earthquake back in September 2010, and this one is technically an aftershock. Although the reading on the richter scale is 6.3 (smaller than the Sept quake) it was shallower and centred right in the city. These people have suffered 6 months of aftershocks, with over 5000 tremors, only to have another big shake devastate their city.

Christchurch Cathedral, before and after the earthquake.
The damage is extreme, with massive high-rise buildings collapsing into themselves, killing many people (death toll currently sitting at 75, there are still 300 missing). Rescue workers are currently searching desperately for survivors. Liquefaction has appeared, with the soil turning to soft grey sludge swallowing cars. Roads have been torn up. Power has been cut, because the sub-stations have sunk into the mud. There have been landslides with boulders and rocks the size of houses squashing buildings. Cars in the central city have been crushed by falling bricks and building facades. Sewer lines are broken and water supplies too, so there is no fresh water. It's unbelievable. I'm watching the extended news coverage showing image after image of terror.

Learn more at the links below, or Google "Christchurch earthquake".

You can also donate to the New Zealand Red Cross here.

Image slideshow of quake damaged Christchurch

News article, most damage in the CBD of Christchurch

Aerial video of damage in Christchurch district

A map of the Christchurch earthquake and aftershocks

New Zealand is a small country and this disaster has just been declared our first ever National State of Emergency.

Monday, February 21, 2011

I tried so hard, but my BG just wouldn't behave!

Ok so today was always going to be stressful and unpredictable: it was the first day of semester, welcoming students and the start of orientation week.

I woke up an hour early to make sure I had time to get dressed and looking presentable, make a tasty packed lunch (smoked warehou fish, green grapes, one plain slice of dark rye bread) and get to work in time to get a good spot at the welcome ceremony. (more on this later).

I was put in a foul mood by having a hypo in the night, and finding that I was sky high in the morning. I though I only ate a tiny bit of emergency food. Perhaps I should have just waited it out?

The commute to work usually takes me 7 mins. Today it was an unholy 28 minutes. I swore. A lot. I was late for the welcoming ceremony...

Here in NZ it's called a powhiri, and it's usually a very touching and moving event, one that makes you feel special to be a part of it. It's led by the Maori elders and the people attending split into two sides: those being welcomed (students) and those doing the welcoming (tutors and faculty staff). There is speech-making in both Te Reo and English, and karakia (songs) are sung by both sides. It's all about ensuring the proper spiritual protocols are followed, and when it goes according to plan it's beautiful. The students get welcomed onto the sacred learning space :)

Well. Nothing was technically wrong with the ceremony but four people fainted and had to be taken away by the first-aiders due to the heat! At 8.30am!!

Stress put me even higher, hitting 19mmol/L directly after the ceremony. And I had been clutching a fruitbar in my sweaty palm - just in case I went low!! Lol better to be safe...

I bolused twice during the morning, and only came back below 10 in the mid afternoon. Thankfully I had no classes to teach today, so it was just lesson planning and office work.


We had a special welcome for the art department students, and it was good to see all their bright nervous faces!

I then had to wait around for my teacher training class (in which I'm a student) which started late afternoon and ran right over dinnertime. D'oh! Luckily hubby had cooked me a tasty dinner when I finally got home.

Felt like I had the day of disaster blood sugars licked.

We popped round to see hubby's parents after dinner, cue tea and biscuits :) nom!

I had a shower, and I find showers either make me high or low afterwards, nor sure why, the heat maybe? Well, I scored a 24.9mmol/L

W.T.F!?

Oh. Yeah. That's right, you're supposed to take insulin with your dinner! Dumbass! Oh what a waste of all that work!

So now it's nearly midnite and I'm sitting up, testing every half hour to check I'm in fact coming down, and not going low. I'm exhausted, just want to go to sleep. Thought I would blog and let you know that you're all helping me stay awake and get my BGs back on track. Pat on your back :D

P.S. Please please please let my BGs behave tomorrow for my first class teaching of the year!

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Tough week

I didn't realize how tiring his week had been until hubby pointed it out to me.

Apart from the obvious stress of having a sick husband (kidney stones) who is in intense pain, this week also saw our office in the mad rush that happens the week before semester starts. Oh my. Tonnes of paperwork and course documentation to get ready for the new and returning students. An orientation week to plan. Lesson plans to write. Oh yeah, this was also the first week I was studying on my tertiary teaching diploma - I have homework! Heavens! I haven't had homework to do for nearly a decade! :P

Our institute also hosted many guest speakers on Wednesday for a academic staff training day, which was interesting and intense, but cut into valuable class prep time.

I tried to organize to get a GP appointment with hubby, but it didn't work out.

So yesterday I got busy on the phone and called hubby's GP (who I am strongly considering switching to, since my GP of 28 years has recently decided to turn into an inconsiderate a-hole) and I made an appointment for next week so I can meet the hubby's GP.

My diabetes endocrinologist emailed back saying he had phoned the same FA Hamilton clinic manager who I spoke to. He didn't get an overly positive response, but it's still fantastic to have a doc willing to help out like this. He asked if I'd been to see the local MP yet, so I stopped procrastinating and booked a time to meet with him too.

Next week will be busy too.

Perhaps this explains why I have bought 3 pairs of shoes in 2 weeks! Ha! All completely necessary of course! Lol.


- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone